Nectar vs. Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress Comparison 2021

Updated on February 23, 2021 While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about how we make money here.
 

Shopping online for a mattress is no easy task, but Nectar and Brooklyn Bedding offer bed-in-a-box mattresses that ship easily and quickly. Both companies offer high-quality mattresses with extended sleep trials and warranties.

Nectar was founded in 2017 and quickly became a popular choice for those looking for a high-quality, affordable memory foam mattress. The company currently only offers one mattress style, the Nectar mattress, but has also expanded its product line to include bed frames, pillows, and bedding. The Nectar mattress, which we focus on for this review, is backed by a 365-night trial and lifetime warranty. It is a memory foam mattress with four layers of premium foam with unique qualities.

Brooklyn Bedding launched in 2009 as one of the first bed-in-a-box options. The two brothers who founded the company have been in the mattress business since 1995 and focus on manufacturing high-quality, affordable mattresses in the United States. By overseeing the entire manufacturing process, the company eliminates the middleman and passes those savings on to the customer. Brooklyn Bedding has expanded its product line to include six mattress styles, bedding, and bed frames. For this review, we focus on the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattress. This mattress has been updated with a hybrid design with Ascension Coils and layers of responsive foam, and is available in three firmness options.

Read on for our full Nectar vs. Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress comparison.

Mattress Construction Comparison

Nectar

The Nectar mattress features an all-foam construction with 4 layers and a Tencel fabric cover. The fabric cover wicks away moisture. The top layer of the Nectar mattress also aids in temperature regulation, as the quilted memory foam facilitates airflow around the body. This 1-inch layer is infused with cooling gel.

The second layer is 3 inches of gel-infused memory foam with a density of 3.5 Pounds per Cubic Foot (PCF). This layer distributes body heat and circulates air with its semi-open cell structure. This allows the mattress to feel cooler than the average memory foam mattress. This layer also provides contouring support and pressure point relief.

The third layer of the Nectar mattress is 1.75 inches of adaptive hi-core memory foam. Nectar is the only direct-to-consumer mattress company that uses this premium foam. It is resilient and responsive and contours to the shape of your body to provide pressure point relief.

The foundation of the mattress is 5.25 inches of high-density, breathable foam with a density of 2.2 PCF. This layer reinforces the comfort layers of memory foam. Nectar foams are CertiPUR-US certified and made without the use of harmful toxins.

Nectar layers

Brooklyn Bedding Signature

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature hybrid mattress has four layers with a quilted foam top. The top 2-inch layer of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress is patented TitanFlex foam. This hyper-elastic foam is a latex-alternative that combines the contouring properties of memory foam with the resilience and pressure point relief of latex. Its open-cell structure is more breathable than memory foam. It is also infused with TitaniumGel for a cooling feel.

The second 2-inch layer is high-density Energex foam. This transition layer provides contouring support and additional contouring. The third layer is a 6-inch base of up to 952 Ascension coils. These individually encased coils are a thinner gauge that allows them to reduce motion transfer while responding to pressure. This layer provides additional contouring support.

The foundation of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress is 1-inch of high-density support foam. The foams used are CertiPUR-US certified and made without the use of harmful toxins.

Brooklyn bedding signature construction

Firmness Comparison

Mattress firmness refers to how comfortable a mattress is. This is typically rated on a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being extremely soft and 10 being extremely firm. However, it is important to note that mattress firmness is subjective. Factors including personal preference, sleeping position, and body weight affect how soft or firm a mattress feels. This makes firmness different for everyone.

Although mattress firmness is subjective, it is important to understand what firmness you are looking for when shopping for a mattress. Medium-Firm is a popular choice, as it balances contouring and support for a range of sleeping positions and body weight. Those who are lighter weight, or sleep consistently on their side, may prefer the softness and gentle contouring of a soft mattress. Those who are heavier, or sleep consistently on their stomach, may prefer a firmer mattress. How comfortable a bed is to you will affect your overall quality of sleep and is an important consideration.

The Nectar mattress is available in one firmness option and is considered medium-firm with a 6 rating on the firmness scale. The combination of foams used provides a firmness that contours to the shape of your body while supporting proper spinal alignment. This firmness is designed to appeal to a wide range of people, whether they sleep on their side, back, or stomach.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress is available in three firmness options: Soft (4); Medium (6); and Firm (8). The ILD of the comfort and transition layers of foam used determines the firmness of the mattress. The soft option is ideal for side sleepers and those who need additional pressure point relief. The medium firmness is listed as its best-selling option and appeals especially to couples and those who change their sleeping position throughout the night. The firm option is ideal for those who sleep on their stomach or back and do not want to feel like they are sinking into the mattress.

Sleep Experience

Mattress firmness is not the only factor in determining a comfortable sleep experience. It is also important to consider temperature control, motion transfer, responsiveness, resilience, edge support, and smell. These elements affect sleep quality and comfort. Read on to see how the Nectar and Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattresses compare.

Temperature Control

Temperature control in a mattress relies on the materials used and the way that the mattress is constructed. Certain materials, like memory foam, tend to absorb and retain heat. In addition, memory foam can prevent airflow around you as you sleep, as it closely conforms to the shape of your body. Innerspring mattresses tend to have increased air circulation, due to the design of the support coils.

The Nectar mattress sleeps cooler than the average memory foam mattress. This is due to the gel memory foam used in the comfort layers, which is more breathable than traditional memory foam. The quilted top layer also promotes air circulation around the body. The base layer of the Nectar mattress is also a breathable foam, which adds airflow throughout the mattress. In addition, the Tencel fabric cover wicks away heat and moisture.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress features TitaniumGel, which regulates body temperature by pulling away heat. The quilted top increases airflow for a cooling feel. The coils also provide air circulation throughout the mattress. The TitanFlex comfort layer of foam is responsive and contouring without the feeling of sinking into the mattress.

Motion Transfer

Motion transfer is an important factor to consider, especially if you share the bed with a partner. This refers to how the mattress responds to movement, and whether or not it prevents it from rippling across the bed. Ideally, a mattress will isolate movement to one area so it is not felt on the other side of the bed. Memory foam reacts to pressure and absorbs motion, making it an ideal material for motion isolation. Depending on coil construction, hybrid and innerspring mattresses may not isolate motion as well.

The Nectar mattress has an all-foam construction with thick comfort layers of memory foam. This allows it to provide optimal motion isolation.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress also has thick layers of foam that absorb movement. The Ascension coils are individually encased, which reduces motion transfer. This gives the Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress better motion isolation than the average hybrid mattress.

Responsiveness

A supportive mattress will respond proportionately to pressure, cushioning areas like the shoulders and hips. This promotes proper spinal alignment. Certain materials are more responsive than others. Memory foam tends to distribute weight evenly by contouring to the shape of your body and cushioning pressure points.

The Nectar mattress contours closely to the shape of your body with its thick layers of memory foam. In addition, the adaptive hi-core foam layer is soft and supportive.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature hybrid mattress features hyper-responsive TitanFlex foam, which contours like memory foam with the responsiveness of latex. In addition, the Energex foam compresses to provide pressure point relief. The thinner, individually wrapped coils of the support base are more responsive than the average innerspring support layer.

Resilience and Bounce

How quickly a mattress returns to its original shape after you change positions or leave the bed is determined by its resilience. Resilience and bounce are important to consider, as both help to facilitate movement. Materials with low resilience return to their original shape slowly, sometimes causing the feeling of being stuck. Mattresses with high resilience and added bounce tend to be better for intimate activity.

The Nectar mattress has an adaptive, hi-core foam layer that is more resilient than typical memory foam. This adds rebound and bounce to the mattress. In addition, the medium-firm feel prevents the feeling of being stuck or sinking in too far.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature hybrid mattress includes a reactive foam that immediately responds when you change positions. The innerspring layer adds bounce to the mattress. These components help to facilitate movement.

Edge Support

Edge support prevents sagging or sinking along the perimeter of the mattress if you are prone to sitting or sleeping on the edge. A reinforced perimeter increases the sleepable surface area of the bed. It also helps those who may have trouble getting out of bed.

The Nectar mattress is designed with edge-to-edge support, due to its high-density foam base and adaptive hi-core foam layer. Due to the thick comfort layers of memory foam, there may be some sinking in that is most noticeable when you sit at the edge of the bed.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress has innerspring coils and high-density foam that provide reinforced edge support. This prevents sagging over time.

Off-gassing and Smell

Off-gassing is common in new mattresses and is typically a result of synthetic materials and/or plastic packaging used.

The Nectar mattress is CertiPUR-US certified and made without the use of harmful chemicals. There may be some odor from the foam or vacuum-sealed packaging, but it is faint and should dissipate within a few hours in a well-ventilated area.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress is also CertiPUR-US certified. Any initial off-gassing smell is faint and should dissipate within a few hours in a well-ventilated room.

 

Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns

When purchasing a mattress online, it is important to consider how the mattress will be shipped to you. As you are unlikely to have seen or felt the mattress in person, it is also essential to consider the sleep trial length and returns process. These details for Nectar and Brooklyn Bedding are outlined below.

NectarBrooklyn Bedding
Delivery feeFree for the contiguous United States; $150 for Alaska and Hawaii Free within the contiguous United States; 125 for Alaska and Hawaii
How is it shipped?Bed-in-a-boxBed-in-a-box
Old mattress removal?Included in the $149 white glove delivery serviceNot available
Sleep trial length365-Night Trial 120-Night Trial
Return cost and processFree returns and company coordinates pick-upFree returns and company coordinates pick-up
Warranty lengthForever Lifetime Warranty10 years
 

Prices, Sizes, and Value

As the Nectar mattress and Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress differ in price, it is important to take your budget into consideration when deciding which one is right for you.

Mattress SizeNectar Brooklyn Bedding Signature
Twin$499$599
Twin XL$569$699
Full$699$849
Queen$799$949
King$999$1,249
California King$999$1,249

The Nectar mattress is slightly more affordable than the Brooklyn Bedding Signature hybrid mattress. Nectar focuses on affordability and quality, offering a memory foam mattress that is below the industry average. Nectar also offers a 365-night sleep trial and lifetime warranty, giving it an advantage in terms of value.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress is still less expensive than the industry average for a luxury hybrid mattress. The company takes steps to keep its mattresses affordable by manufacturing the mattresses and eliminating the middleman. The construction of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature hybrid mattress is also more complex than that of the Nectar mattress.

Both mattresses are designed with durability and affordability in mind.

 

Nectar Mattress vs. Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress – Which One Should You Buy?

Even considering all of the above factors, you may find it difficult to make a decision. After all, both the Nectar mattress and the Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress are well-designed, quality mattresses at an affordable price point. We created the below list of differentiators to help you decide.

Buy the Nectar mattress if you:

1. Need your old mattress removed

For an additional charge, Nectar offers White Glove Delivery with mattress set-up and old mattress removal. This is not a service that Brooklyn Bedding currently provides.

2. Want more time to sleep on it

Nectar offers a 365-night sleep trial, giving you a full year to sleep on the mattress and decide if it’s right for you.

3. Find peace of mind in a lifetime warranty

Nectar is newer to the mattress industry, but offers a lifetime warranty for its mattress. Both Nectar and Brooklyn Bedding build high-quality mattresses designed to last, but the Nectar warranty is longer.

Nectar Mattress
 

Buy the Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress if you:

1. Want to choose your firmness

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress is offered in three firmness options, allowing you to choose the firmness that best suits your preferences.

2. Tend to sleep hot

Both the Nectar mattress and the Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress take measures to regulate temperature and maintain a cool sleeping environment. With added airflow from the innerspring coils and the TitaniumGel infused comfort layers, Brooklyn Bedding has a slight advantage when it comes to sleeping cool.

3. Prefer a little more bounce

The innerspring coils and resilient comfort layers add more bounce to the Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress. This helps to facilitate movement and may make the mattress more ideal for intimate activity.

Brooklyn Signature sideshot

Both Brooklyn Bedding and Nectar have solid reputations in the mattress industry for building high-quality mattresses. Either mattress would be a sound investment in a comfortable night’s sleep. The Brooklyn Bedding Signature hybrid mattress features responsive innerspring coils and patented foam for contouring support. The Nectar mattress features premium memory foam and high-quality construction. Which mattress is right for you will depend on personal preferences. But if you are deciding between these two mattresses, you can feel confident that either choice would provide a restful night’s sleep for years to come.

See how Nectar and Brooklyn Bedding Signature compare to other mattresses: