Nectar vs. Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Mattress Comparison 2021

Updated on January 24, 2021 While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.
 

There are a lot of mattresses available online today, but it’s difficult to judge them side by side. To help with this, we’ve created an in-depth comparison of the Nectar mattress and the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora mattress.

Nectar is a mattress-in-a-box bedding company that has gained popularity since its start in 2017. It only offers one bed—The Nectar mattress—which has an all-foam construction. Although it is only available in one firmness option, the premium materials and affordable price is hard to beat.

Producing sleeping products since 1995, Brooklyn Bedding’s newest model is the Aurora mattress. This hybrid bed comes in three firmness levels and includes features to help you stay cool throughout the night. The company is known for making high-quality products, and this option is a great pick for hot sleepers who want some choices for their next bed.

Mattress Construction Comparison

Nectar

The Nectar is an 11-inch foam mattress that’s composed of four distinct layers. The comfort layer is made out of quilted memory foam which is covered by Tencel. Underneath the comfort layer is three inches of gel memory foam with a density of 3.5 pounds per cubic foot (PCF). The top two layers help with pressure point relief. The third layer of the mattress uses Adaptive Hi Core Memory Foam to give the bed a bit more bounce, which is often lacking in foam construction. The base layer is made of 2.2 PCF support foam and has an anti-slip cover on the bottom to help keep the mattress in place.

Brooklyn Bedding Aurora

The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora mattress is a 13-inch bed divided into five layers. The outer layer uses a smooth top weave called TitanCool, which is a great feature for hot sleepers. The comfort layer uses an inch and a half of Energex foam infused with copper gel. The foam has a density of 3.5 PCF and an indentation load deflection (ILD) of 12. The second layer uses Brooklyn Bedding’s TitanFlex polyfoam with a PCF of 3.5 and varying ILD ratings based on firmness choice: Soft has an ILD of 10, Medium has an ILD of 18, and Firm has an ILD of 36. The transition layer is one inch of gel-swirl memory foam that helps with contouring and has added cooling qualities. This layer has a density of 3.5 PCF. The fourth layer consists of 1,189 individually encased innerspring coils, which sit on top of the fifth layer; a one-inch support layer made of polyfoam.

Firmness Comparison

One of the most noticeable and important factors in picking a new mattress is its firmness. Firmness is a rating that tells you how hard or soft the bed feels. Since each person is different, there are many options which are measured on a scale of 1-10. A 1 is the softest mattress while a 10 is the firmest, with average sleepers preferring medium (5) to medium-firm (7).

The Nectar mattress falls right in the middle of this range at a 6. While this is a good starting point to judge firmness, some sleepers can find this too firm. Firmness preferences can be affected by a person’s weight and sleeping position. The Aurora mattress has three firmness options, and its Medium bed is just about the same as the Nectar with a 5-6 rating. The Soft option is around 3, and the Firm option is between 7-8.

Lighter individuals who sleep on their side and people who like to sink into their mattress will enjoy the soft option form Brooklyn Bedding. Stomach sleepers and heavier individuals will prefer the Firm option. People who fall in the middle will find the Medium Aurora bed and the Nectar mattress are fairly even in firmness.

Sleep Experience

With so many different elements in the mix, it is essential to know how your future mattress performs in certain areas. The position in which you sleep as well as the amount of heat your body tends to give off can affect how a bed works for you. Each of the following categories is an important factor to consider when comparing the Nectar mattress to The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora mattress.

Temperature Control

Foam mattresses are notorious for trapping heat. The Nectar mattress does better than most when it comes to heat retention; however, the Aurora still has it beat. Brooklyn Bedding includes numerous features to help keep you cool while you sleep. TitanCool, a phase changing material, absorbs heat and releases it away from your body. The copper fibers in the Energex foam also help drive away heat, and the innerspring core gives the most airflow. The Nectar uses two layers of gel memory foam that does offer better cooling than regular foam, but hot sleepers may find the heat retention uncomfortable.

Motion Transfer

Both the Nectar and Aurora mattresses do a good job with motion isolation, but the Nectar’s foam construction gives it a slight edge. The foam layers absorb almost all motion that would usually be transferred across a bed’s surface. The Nectar mattress’s use of memory foam, which is four inches of the bed’s construction, improves upon the already excellent motion isolation. As a hybrid bed, the Aurora also has the benefit of using thick foam for its comfort layer. The Soft and Medium options offer above-average motion isolation, but ultimately, the innerspring base makes this model slightly worse than the Nectar.

Responsiveness

The Nectar mattress easily conforms to your body thanks to the double layers of memory foam. With the Aurora mattress, the responsiveness will depend on which firmness option you choose. The Soft option will conform to your body the most with a very low ILD of 12, and the Firm option has the least amount of give with its ILD of 36. The Nectar lands in the middle of the Aurora’s Firm and Medium options.

Resilience and Bounce

The overall resilience of the Nectar is less than the Aurora due to the type of mattress. However, the high-quality gel memory foam used helps combat some of these issues. Like most foam mattresses, the Nectar responds to heat and pressure, so there is a limited bounce. The innerspring coils and TitanFlex foam helps give the Aurora a good amount of bounce that can easily accommodate sex. Brooklyn Bedding’s use of memory foam as a comfort layer does take away some of the resilience you’d expect from a hybrid model.

Edge Support

While edge support is not either of these two mattress’s strong point, the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora mattress performs slightly better. The strong support from the innerspring coils helps keep you from sinking in too far when sitting on the edge of this bed. The Nectar is constructed entirely of foam, which compresses when weight is applied. While the density of its base layer helps, the Nectar mattress doesn’t have excellent edge support overall.

Off-gassing and Smell

Foam mattresses often have an odor when they’re first unpackaged. The scent is from the manufacturing process and is completely non-toxic. The Nectar mattress is made entirely of foam and also has additional treatment for its compression process. The Aurora also has a mild smell when first unboxed. In both cases, the smell will go away after several hours of sitting in a ventilated room.

 

Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns

The table below helps you get an idea of how purchasing, delivery, and possible returns would work based on the mattress company’s policies. It’s important to know all the details and fine print of your selection.

NectarBrooklyn Bedding Aurora
Delivery feeFree for the contiguous United States; $150 for Alaska and Hawaii Free for the contiguous United States; $75 for Alaska and Hawaii; $150 for Canada
How is it shipped?Bed-in-a-boxBed-in-a-box
Old mattress removal?Available for a feeNot available
Sleep trial length365-Night Trial 120-Night Trial
Return cost and processFree returns and company coordinates pick-upFull refund, customer responsible for disposal/donation
Warranty lengthForever Lifetime Warranty10-Year Limited Warranty
 

Prices, Sizes, and Value

Buying a mattress is a big purchase, both based on price and based on how much it affects your daily life. You want to find the best bed that makes your total investment worth it. The table below outlines the prices of the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora mattress vs Nectar mattress.

Mattress SizeNectarBrooklyn Bedding Aurora
Twin$499$999
Twin XL$569$1,249
Full$699$1,549
Queen$799$1,699
King$999$2,124
California King$999$2,124

The Nectar mattress is by far cheaper than the Aurora, but that’s to be expected based on the type of beds they are. Brooklyn Bedding has a well priced hybrid mattress that lands about average for its category. Nectar made a name for itself by offering low priced bedding products with premium materials, and The Nectar mattress is slightly cheaper than your average foam bed. While it makes for a more attractive offer, the Aurora also comes with better additional features (firmness options, white glove delivery, and mattress removal), so the best deal depends on what’s most important for you.

 

Nectar Mattress vs. Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Mattress – Which One Should You Buy?

While we’ve outlined in detail the similarities and differences of these two mattresses, below is a quick and comprehensive overview of why you might want one over the other.

Buy the Nectar mattress if you:

1. Are on a budget

The Nectar mattress is by far the less expensive option, not only beating the Aurora but also selling for less than the average foam mattress.

2. Want good trial and warranty options

Nectar gives its customers a full one-year trial to test out its mattress, and each bed comes with a lifetime warranty.

3. Want a medium-firm foam bed

While this mattress doesn’t come with different firmness or material options, it does outperform other beds in its class.

Buy the Aurora mattress if you:

1. Want different firmness options

The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora mattress has three different firmness options that can accommodate a person’s specific sleeping style.

2. Are a hot sleeper

The Aurora goes above and beyond to make a cool sleeping surface. The phase-changing material, copper fibers, and innerspring coils give you the most breathability.

3. Like a mattress with bounce

The innerspring core of the Aurora mattress coupled with the gel-infused memory foam gives this bed more resilience and bounce than the Nectar.

When it comes to Nectar vs Brooklyn Bedding, both companies offer excellent products that share a lot of features. Picking the one that is best for you ultimately depends on your style. The Nectar mattress is an affordable foam bed with incredible deals. You can try out this medium-firm mattress for a full year, get it shipped with white glove delivery and mattress removal, and it comes with a lifetime warranty. The Aurora mattress is a better option for someone who wants options in their bed. The three different firmness options give you a good variety, and the Aurora is ideal for hot sleepers.

See how the Nectar compares to other mattresses: