The Best Pillow Top Mattress 2021Updated on March 3, 2021 While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about how we make money here.
Falling asleep in the lap of luxury: it’s what dreams are made of. And though sometimes this is only associated with fancy hotels and resorts, the truth is that you can capture this feeling, at least when it comes to the bed, in your own home. One of the best ways to do this is with a pillow top mattress that can coax you to sleep with its soft, welcoming feel.
In this guide, we’ll introduce you to pillow top mattresses, their benefits and drawbacks, and we’ll list our four picks for the best pillow top mattresses available on the market today.
Our Top Picks
|Brand||Model||Mattress Type||Firmness||Price (Queen)|
|WinkBed||Innerspring||4 options: Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7), Plus (8)||$1,599|
|Helix Midnight Luxe||Hybrid||Medium Firm (6)||$1,849|
|Saatva Classic||Innerspring||3 options: Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7)||$1,499|
|DreamCloud||Hybrid||Medium Firm (6.5)||$1,299|
|Beautyrest Black||Hybrid||2 options: Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6)||$2,299|
Why we like it:
- Top-notch edge support relative to most pillow top mattresses
- Choice of three firmness options
- Hybrid design promotes bounce and contouring
The WinkBed mattress uses a combination of foam, micro-coils, and pocketed coils to give their mattress a feeling of luxury while also providing support and bounce. The mattress is offered in three firmness levels including medium soft (4), medium firm (6), and firm (7), as well as the “WinkBed Plus” (8) specifically designed for people who weigh at least 230 pounds. Each of these models includes a pillow top.
The pillow top is made with two layers of polyfoam. The topmost is 1.5 inches of a latex-like polyfoam that offers more bounce without excessive sink. The second is 1.5 inches of polyfoam infused with gel. The use of these two distinct foams works to let the mattress contour to the body without swallowing it whole. These foams are sewn into the pillowtop underneath the Tencel cover of the bed.
Underneath these two foam layers is 2.5 inches of micro-coils that are foam-encased for extra responsiveness. Beneath the micro-coils is the support core that is built with 7.5 inches of pocketed innerspring coils, giving even more bounce and support for the bed. There is also a foam shell around the outermost part of the coils in order to create best-in-class edge support, something that is frequently lacking in other pillow top mattresses.
This hybrid design brings a lot to the table in terms of performance, and with a 120-night sleep trial and a track record of happy customers, the WinkBed clearly makes the list for our best pillow top mattresses.
Helix Midnight Luxe
Why we like it:
- Medium firm feel balances a plush surface feel with strong support
- Memory foam contours evenly to reduce pressure along the spine
- Zoned coils protect the edges from deep sinkage
- 100-night sleep trial and 15-year warranty
Helix Sleep offers an extensive line of hybrid mattresses specifically designed for certain body types and sleep positions. The Midnight Luxe is a pillow-top hybrid with a medium firm (6) feel and two memory foam comfort layers. While the surface has a plush feel that makes getting in and out of bed more comfortable, a transitional polyfoam later and pocketed coil support core reinforce the mattress very well to prevent you from sinking too deeply.
The coils are also zoned with thicker hardware around the perimeter, so you shouldn’t sink too much when you sleep near the edges of the mattress or get in and out of bed. Pressure relief is another strong point of the Midnight Luxe, particularly for side and back sleepers who weigh up to 230 pounds. The memory foam provides gentle yet precise contouring to cradle the spine and alleviate pressure points that pop up around the shoulders, lower back, and hips.
As part of the Luxe series, this model’s price-point is on the higher end. To sweeten the deal for customers, Helix Sleep provides free shipping throughout the U.S. and backs the mattress with a 100-night sleep trial. You’ll also receive a 15-year warranty against structural defects should you decide to keep the Midnight Luxe after the trial period expires.
Why we like it:
- Foam-filled Euro top with memory foam lumbar pad
- Coil-on-coil interior construction
- Free White Glove delivery
The Saatva mattress is an example of the excellent results that can come about through the combination of attentive design and quality materials. The mattress is available in different heights (11.5 or 14.5 inches) and three different firmness levels (medium soft, medium firm, or firm), providing customers with the opportunity to select the specific model that is most likely to fit their needs.
In all of the models, you’ll find a quilted Euro top. The material inside the Euro top is polyfoam that provides softness and tends to hold up well compared to many fiber materials. Additional polyfoam and a lumbar pad made of memory foam are underneath this layer to offer extra support, especially near the lower back. Beneath this is a 4-inch layer of pocketed micro-coils. These coils are able to compress in isolation from the adjacent coils, which gives the mattress more responsiveness and ability to support spinal alignment. This also helps to reduce motion isolation.
The support core of the Saatva mattress is a base of Bonnell innerspring coils. If you opt for the 14.5-inch model, this layer of coils is 7 inches thick. In the 11.5-inch mattress, these coils are 4 inches thick. The Bonnell coils offer bounce, stability, and durability to the bed as a whole.
The Saatva mattress comes with an added benefit: free White Glove delivery. Included in your purchase price is installation of the bed in your bedroom as well as haul-away of an old mattress if necessary. With a 120-night sleep trial, a quality service reputation, a history of customer satisfaction, and a reasonable price, the Saatva is a clear pick for our list of the best pillow top mattresses.
Why we like it:
- Contouring, gel-infused memory foam in pillow top
- Soft, breathable cashmere blend cover
- Luxurious high-profile desigh
- 365-night sleep trial and lifetime warranty
The DreamCloud Premier mattress employs a design with a significant number of layers including a plush pillow top made of gel-infused memory foam. The cover is made with a cashmere and polyester blend that offers additional softness and a luxurious feel to the mattress.
The DreamCloud Premier falls between a pillow top and Euro-top. While there is a clear visual difference in the topmost layer, the stitching is more akin to a Euro-top. However, where this mattress really shines is that it employs high-end material in the pillow top. Instead of just using a basic fiber fill, its gel-infused memory foam provides much greater responsiveness and motion isolation. It is also a material that is more likely to hold up well over time.
Underneath the top layers, the DreamCloud Premier employs cushioning layers of memory foam and adaptive polyfoam, and a support core of foam-encased innerspring coils that have a cushioning bottom layer of memory foam. All of these materials contribute to a sleeping surface that meets all kinds of needs — bounce, plushness, and responsiveness. Though the pillow top gives this mattress a welcoming feel, its overall firmness level falls around a 6.5 on the typical firmness scale.
A considerable plus for the DreamCloud Premier is that the mattress comes with a 365-night sleep trial, giving you a full year to test out the mattress risk-free. It is backed by a lifetime warranty that covers mattress defects.
Why we like it:
- Deep comfort system ensures above-average pressure relief for a hybrid
- Thicker coils around the edges increase perimeter stability
- Upgrades available for added cooling and a firmer feel
- Free White Glove delivery
The Beautyrest Black epitomizes the term luxury pillow-top hybrid. The mattress is features soft foam quilted into the cover, followed by three layers of adaptive and transitional foam over a support core of pocketed coils. These foam layers mold closely to hug the body and distribute your weight, resulting in excellent pressure relief for side sleepers weighing across all body types – particularly those in the range of 130-230 pounds. Back and stomach sleepers who weigh up to 230 pounds should also find this mattress comfortable.
Customers can upgrade their Black with extra features to enhance their sleep experience. The “Cooling” upgrade adds two layers of gel-infused memory foam designed to draw heat away from your body and help the mattress maintain a comfortable temperature. The “Comfort” upgrade increases the thickness of the top foam layer, changing the Black’s feel from medium firm (6) to medium soft (4).
Regardless of whether or not you choose these upgrades, the Black excels at edge support thanks to stronger coils places along the perimeter. The thick foam layers also absorb movement quite well, so the mattress offers above-average motion isolation for couples compared to other coil-based models.
Beautyrest is one of the only online mattress companies in the country to offer free White Glove delivery to its customers. This service includes full assembly in a room of your choice and removal of your old mattress at no extra charge. Your purchase will also include a 100-night sleep trial and 10-year warranty.
Best Pillow Top Mattress Buying Guide
What is a Pillow Top Mattress?
In a pillow top mattress, there is a layer of soft material that is stitched to the top of the mattress above the standard comfort layer. Visually, you can identify a pillow top mattress immediately because it looks like there is a thin pillow or separate layer covering the entire mattress surface.
The most common thickness of a pillow top is around 3”. The material used in a pillow top may include cotton, synthetic fiber, foam, or many other materials.
The goal of a pillow top is to provide additional softness, comfort, and/or responsiveness to the mattress. While a pillow top can be put on any mattress type, you are most likely to find it on an innerspring mattress because it can provide a plusher feel than the springs alone.
How is a Pillow Top Different From a Euro Top?
A Euro Top is also a layer of material on top of the mattress that is designed to give more comfort. Like a pillow top, a Euro Top is usually around 3” thick and generally made of fiber fill. However, a Euro Top usually has several important differences:
- Sewing and layering: in a Euro Top, the extra material is layered directly on top of the mattress and is sewn together under the same cover. As a result, a Euro Top is not as visually apparent because it fits more seamlessly with the other layers of the mattress.
- Material style and feel: Euro Tops usually have either more material or denser material and are not quite as pillowy in feel.
- Edge support: many Euro Tops are built to be softer toward the center with reinforcement around the exterior to improve edge support.
- Longevity: Euro Tops tend to hold their shape longer than pillow tops because of the nature of the material that is used. That said, with time, Euro Tops will also soften and wear out, including around the edges.
The choice about whether to pick a pillow top or a Euro Top depends in large part on your preference for how the mattress will look and feel. If you want a sleeker look for your mattress or a less plush feel, a Euro Top is likely to be a better option than a pillow top.
The Benefits and Drawbacks of Pillow Top Mattresses
- Plushness for comfort: if you want the closest thing you can find to sleeping on a cloud, a pillow top may be your best bet. Some people describe the feel of a pillow top as “regal” because it has that inviting plushness that some sleepers crave.
- Affordability: while some plush beds are extremely expensive, many pillow tops are available at accessible prices through the use of less-expensive fiber materials in the pillow top layer.
- Pain relieving: having a mattress that is too firm can cause a lot of impact at joints and can put pressure on those joints that can lead to pain. A pillow top, by offering 3” of extra cushioning, can help decrease this impact and reduce this problem.
- Less motion transfer: by permitting more sink into the top of the bed, a pillow top can make it harder for motion by one person to be felt by a partner who is sharing the bed.
- Good for side sleepers: pillow top mattresses are most popular among side sleepers because they can provide extra cushioning and softness to avoid painful impact at the pressure points of the hips and shoulders. Depending on the firmness and support of the rest of the mattress, a pillow top may be an option for back and stomach sleepers as well.
- Breaking down: while the materials that are put to use in a pillow top are soft and inviting, they are not necessarily the most durable. Because the pillow top bears the brunt of the pressure of your body on the bed, it’s common for these materials to start to lose their loft and plushness with time. This can manifest as sagging of the top layer, and it can also show up disproportionately based on where you apply the most pressure as you sleep, leading to irregular indentations.
- Heat retention: when you sink into a bed, there is more direct contact with your skin, which can cause your skin to heat up. Because air can’t flow around your body, your natural cooling processes are disrupted. As this happens, the pillow top’s material itself can retain heat. All of these factors can make a pillow top sleep hot, which may disrupt many sleepers.
- Inadequate support: it’s important to note that softness is not the same thing as support. Even though a pillow top may feel comfortable, it may not offer the kind of cushioning that your body needs to remain in proper alignment.
For all of these reasons, we usually recommend a hybrid mattress, including hybrids featuring a pillow top, over an innerspring mattress with a simple pillow top above the coils. A hybrid tends to have more responsiveness and more resilience (bounce), and this means that it normally does more to promote spinal alignment while avoiding issues (such as sleeping hot) that relate to excessive sinking into the bed.
A hybrid is also normally built with better materials that have a greater propensity to last. However, all of that said, if you’re on a tight budget, a hybrid may not be in the cards, and a pillow-top is worthy of your consideration.